*DrewGreen

Neato!

+Watch Send a Note Give

Do you read the comments of other artists on a piece that you like?

93%

401 deviants said Yes.

29 deviants said No.

Devious Comments

~hirayagi-ellery Jul 24, 2010 Professional Digital Artist

YEP! I ALWAYS DO. i want to know if they felt the same way when i see that certain art

~callumCRUNCH Jul 23, 2010 Digital Artist

I'm always reading comments/replies on others' work.
I usually skim pointless "OMG SO AWESUM" comments, but I do read through the ones that give good criticism or actually say something constructive.

*DrewGreen Jul 23, 2010

Haha, yes, there are a lot of those simple, positive comments. They're nice to receive, I suppose, but it does get a little old after awhile.

~callumCRUNCH Jul 26, 2010 Digital Artist

Yeah, totally! But I really don't mind it, because I don't get a lot anyhow.

=Vashtastic Jul 23, 2010 Digital Artist

i skim and try to make sure i'm not asking a question that's already been answered.

*DrewGreen Jul 23, 2010

I try to do that too.

*paperfetish Jul 23, 2010

I usually skim through the short replies and look for the comments with opinions about the piece. I almost always pick up something new every time.

*DrewGreen Jul 23, 2010

That's not surprising, your comments tend to have a decent amount of depth and thought to them. ;D

*beblue Jul 23, 2010 Student General Artist

I read the artist's comments, but not generally the replies. Frankly, they're usually one of two things:

1) Inane, mindless fangirl squeeing
2) Needlessly rude/cruel critiques.

But then, I also rarely comment myself. (; If I like something, I fav it instead of contributing one of these two crap comments...

*DrewGreen Jul 23, 2010

I don't think it's so bad to leave a simple, positive comment, but I definitely wish there were more comments that had thought put into them. I try to mention the things that I like about the image and (if applicable) things that I think could be done better to improve for the future.

Poll History

May 23, 2011 How many Daily Deviations have you had?
May 2, 2011 Where would you like to see my art and original characters?
Apr 5, 2011 Stupid question, but...favorite kind of art out of these options?
Mar 18, 2011 I feel like I know the answer already, but I'll ask anyway. Favorite color method for a comic?
Mar 1, 2011 Do you feel more comfortable paying half for a commission up front then the rest at the end, or paying in full up front?
Feb 28, 2011 When an artist is open about their sexual orientation in their art, do you find it off-putting?
Feb 12, 2011 Which outlet do you think is best for sharing artwork (aside from Deviantart)?
Feb 7, 2011 In what format do you prefer buying/owning comics?
Jan 28, 2011 Favorite series of Mega Man?
Jan 12, 2011 Who is your favorite?
Dec 16, 2010 Do you like it when artists feature other artists in their DA journal?
Oct 26, 2010 What night of the week is best for a livestream?
Oct 23, 2010 How do you feel about human cartoon characters wtih only 4 fingers instead of 5?
Oct 18, 2010 Favorite color (in a broad sense)?
Oct 2, 2010 Which would you like to be more?
Sep 30, 2010 What is the best day for a web comic to update?
Sep 23, 2010 Would you be interested in watching me do a livestream while sketching or something?
Sep 8, 2010 What is your sexual orientation? (Votes are anonymous, but comments are not, keep that in mind)
Sep 7, 2010 Are you a male or a female?
Aug 29, 2010 How do you feel about themed art books? (An art book with several images by one artist with a particular focus or theme.)
Aug 12, 2010 Did the unveiling of DA Muro seem anti-climactic to you?
Aug 9, 2010 What name do you use to refer to me?
Aug 3, 2010 I plan on making a tutorial (maybe a few). What tutorial would you MOST like to see me create?
Jul 29, 2010 Do you consider it an insult when someone compares your style to that of a more established artist?
Jul 25, 2010 Are you tired of Daily Deviations that are basically just tutorials on how to use DA's many features?
Jul 23, 2010 Do you read the comments of other artists on a piece that you like?
Jul 21, 2010 Are low-resolution images on a person's gallery off-putting to you enough to keep you from faving or commenting?
Jul 14, 2010 Do you play video games on a regular basis? (Simply, are you a gamer?)
Jul 7, 2010 So, how old are you, watchers? (Remember, answers are anonymous)
Jun 20, 2010 So...
May 31, 2010 You say "Nice art!" Artist replies "thank you!" You reply...
May 30, 2010 How do you feel about non-art-related journal entries on DA?
May 27, 2010 Do you appreciate a finished comic page as a complete piece of art?
May 20, 2010 Do you read the Artist's Comments?
May 18, 2010 So, DA Version 7. Like it or hate it?
May 16, 2010 Ninjas and pirates are, like, so 5 minutes ago, and vampires are out the door (I hope). So what now?
May 14, 2010 Ever joined a DA club that you wish you hadn't joined (and are too lazy to leave)?
May 12, 2010 So...
May 11, 2010 Is it wrong not to thank a new watcher who has no art in their gallery?
May 10, 2010 Do you consider vexel art "cheating?"
Jan 1, 2010 Is having a narrator for a comic "cheating?" (comments help, too)
Nov 8, 2009 Which of my original properties is your favorite? (further comments appreciated, as well)
Oct 25, 2009 Should I change my avatar?
May 3, 2008 What motivates you to join an art contest?
Jan 12, 2008 Does a Web Comic or Web Animation have to be comedic to be worth viewing on a weekly basis?
Sep 11, 2007 Would you enter a contest if I decided to hold one?

Advertise | Premium Membership

Etiquette | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Copyright Policy

*DrewGreen

Do you read the comments of other artists on a piece that you like?

Devious Comments

Poll History

Add Media

Style